No prison costs to be introduced in opposition to tax officials in childcare gains scandal

Photo: Bic by using Wikimedia Commons

The Dutch tax business office will not be billed with discriminating from mothers and fathers concerned in the childcare profit scandal soon after the community prosecution services dominated it had no situation to answer.

Prosecutors began an criminal investigation after tax ministers Alexandra van Huffelen and Hans Vijlbrief submitted an official complaint versus the tax service in May well. Legal advisers claimed there was a ‘reasonable suspicion’ that crimes had been fully commited.

1000’s of mom and dad were being requested to pay back back again tens of 1000’s of euros in allowances to satisfy the expense of out-of-college childcare soon after they ended up deemed to be defrauding the procedure.

In several circumstances the accusation was primarily based on minimal omissions in paperwork these as a lacking signature, but mom and dad were blocked from accessing monetary help, barred from implementing for gains in long run many years and denied any ideal of attractiveness. An internal inquiry concluded that the label of ‘deliberate or extreme debt’ was wrongly applied in 96% of cases.

All-around 11,000 mother and father were being also subjected to further checks for the reason that they experienced dual nationality, even although municipalities have been barred from recording 2nd nationalities in their citizens’ sign up to reduce these types of discrimination.

The prosecution service inquiry focused on whether officials were guilty of systemic discrimination in opposition to mothers and fathers, the wide bulk of whom had minority ethnic backgrounds, or a crime regarded as ‘knevelarij’, which requires the ‘deliberate and wrongful demanding of payments by a civil servant’.

A parliamentary inquiry in the autumn concluded that mom and dad caught up in the affair experienced been the victims of an ‘unparalleled wrong’ by civil servants, ministers and judges. The inquiry’s scope was restricted to exclude the problem of discrimination since of the prosecution service’s inquiry.

‘No suspicion of a crime’

‘After mindful thought of the information and situation, the OM [prosecution department] has uncovered no suspicion of prison activity,’ it explained in a statement.

It explained civil servants could not be suspected of wrongfully demanding payments mainly because the criminal offense of ‘knevelarij’ only handles payments that are due to community coffers, whilst the rewards in issue were being owed to the mothers and fathers.

The tax office is immune from prosecution as an arm of the state and that security extends to its employees as long as they observe its policies and protocols, the OM noted. Tax business staff members were entitled to believe that they were acting inside of the principles in demanding repayments from parents, partly mainly because the observe had been endorsed in a judgment by the administrative division of the Council of State.

Twin nationality

The prosecution provider also concluded that dual nationality was employed to pick out mothers and fathers for added scrutiny, the remaining determination was manufactured on an specific foundation. ‘Nationality no longer played a position in the perseverance,’ the assertion said.

The prosecution company acknowledged that the tax office’s techniques ‘had pretty unjust effects in lots of conditions,’ but concluded that this was a political matter. ‘The corrective mechanism for insurance policies that are judged in hindsight to be “wrong” does not lie in legal legislation in this scenario,’ it mentioned.

It explained mom and dad who continue to felt aggrieved could attractiveness straight to the courts to buy a legal investigation underneath Post 12 of the Dutch penal code.


Thank you for donating to

The group would like to thank all the generous viewers who have built a donation in current weeks. Your economic aid has served us to expand our coverage of the coronavirus crisis into the evenings and weekends and make confident you are retained up to day with the most recent developments. has been no cost for 14 many years, but with no the financial backing of our visitors, we would not be ready to supply you with honest and exact news and features about all points Dutch. Your contributions make this attainable.

If you have not nevertheless designed a donation, but would like to, you can do so by means of Best, credit card or Paypal.